Being a Foreigner in Sicily: Guest Blogger Valerie Mai Hughes


I am so pleased to host Veronica Mai Hughes, who writes the wildly successful blog The Dangerously Truthful Diary of a Sicilian Housewife.  Valerie, a UK native, lives with her Sicilian born husband and their two sons in a small fishing village in Sicily. She and I have both talked about the difficulties inherent in the “outsider” acclimating themselves to Sicilian society.  When I asked her to be a guest blogger, she agreed, and chose this topic.  While she and I may differ on a  few points, she offers here a very personal and very vivid account of her own experiences. Food for thought!  I ask the reader though, if Veronica, an educated , married and economically stable woman experiences difficulties in Sicilian society, just imagine the plight of the refugee.

Being a Foreigner in Sicily

By Veronica Mai Hughes


Ten years ago in London, just before I moved to Sicily, an Italian colleague told me
“You can’t go to Sicily. Outsiders can’t cope there.”

 I sometimes, perhaps often, wish I had listened to him and called the whole thing off, made my husband move to London, and continued thinking Sicily was wonderful by only visiting the place on holidays.

 Instead I came to live here, and discovered that being an outsider in Sicily means just that – being an outsider. Having a Sicilian husband does not always give you a free pass. I have attended many a social function where I was treated like an Imam at a Bar  Mitzvah.

 Perhaps because Sicilians have been invaded so many times, they have a profound mistrust of anyone or anything from outside the island. Over centuries, they have failed to fend off foreign invaders over and over again. Instead they made their foreign enemies’ lives as troublesome as possible by shunning them, lying to them and tricking them at every turn.


Fitting in

It’s difficult to fit in sometimes.

When I am having one of my bad days, I sometimes feel that this Sicilian way of treating foreigners has become such an integral part of their culture that they do not know how to stop.

 This suspicion of anyone from outside their island, their town, even their own family, is so profound that cousin marriage is still very common. So common, in fact, that when you are admitted to hospital in Sicily, the folder for holding your medical notes has a special box for the doctor to tick if your parents are blood relations of each other. That way, the doctors are alerted to look out for genetic disorders. Despite the vastly diverse origins of their gene pool, this inbreeding means that a whopping six percent of modern Sicilians have Mediterranean Anaemia, a devastating genetic disease. My husband’s parents are cousins and his family carries this disease. Before we in-laws could marry into the family, we had to have a test to make sure we were free of the deadly gene.

 If you are an outsider in Sicily, you will always be one. I am still routinely charged double for fruit and vegetables, given the bad bits of meat, and even overcharged in the supermarket. I have to be vigilant every time I buy something, adding up the prices and checking my change. I have to be subtle about it too. I had one woman ranting about “foreigners who come from who-knows-where” outside my son’s school once when I had been too obvious in the way I checked the change she gave me.

Ummm, okay.


I have found it supremely difficult to make friends with Sicilian women. This baffles me, as I have made friends with hundreds of people of all nationalities with ease – and kept those friends for life. Do the women of Sicily feel threatened because I have a masters degree in Classics whereas most of them have a University of Life diploma in ironing tablecloths and a doctorate in stain removal? Do they think I will use my Protestant background to subvert their children’s Catholic indoctrination? Do they feel it is a waste of time making me like them, because I have no social network here and will therefore never be useful to them? All of the above.


One Sicilian friend of my husband’s, who is about ten years older than me and one of the few people who has been genuinely friendly to me, told me she was shunned by her entire village when she did her degree. They disapproved of a woman having an education.
“I was more evolved than the rest of them and they felt threatened,” she said. “It made me an outsider. Once you’re an outsider, you can’t get back in.”


Out for good?


I remind myself of this every time I feel that invisible line separating me from everyone else. Sicilians don’t just shun foreigners like me. They do it to each other too. Whilst this is not a positive thing, it does offer me a little consolation on those awfully lonely days when I feel like crying.

 Sicilian society works on the basis of doing favours and making others indebted to you. Then you call in favours when you need them. I have made many “friends” who happened to need something translated into English. I spent hours doing free translations then, when I asked for a small favour in return, they just said no. When it comes to outsiders in Sicily, they can break the rules. We don’t matter.



The foreigners who live in Sicily form their own support networks. There is a ghetto of Bangladeshis in central Palermo.
“They don’t want anything to do with us,” one Sicilian man moaned to me. “Why do they come here if they don’t want to mix? The Vucciria market has died because the foreigners who live in that area only buy their food from each other’s shops.”
“How many of those foreigners have you chatted to? Or invited to take a coffee with you in a bar, or come to your house?” I asked him.
He looked at me strangely.
“What would I want to do that for?”


It is just a cup of coffee!

At last, after ten years, I have made two close Sicilian friends. Their children go to my son’s school, so I see them fairly often when we collect our kids. One of them was rejected by former friends who decided she was not rich and thin enough to be a part of their clique any more: she knows how outsiders feel. The other caught tuberculosis and was treated, literally, like a leper by all the other parents at her son’s preschool.

 Perhaps this has given them special insight into how outsiders feel. Perhaps they are just nicer than the average Sicilian. Whatever the reason, I am so grateful for their friendship. Without them, I would have given up by now, and fled this beautiful, irrational, maddening little island.


Tagged , , ,

2 thoughts on “Being a Foreigner in Sicily: Guest Blogger Valerie Mai Hughes

  1. As a Sicilian ‘outside’ from a long while, hey, that’s just how I feel in UK (will not say where) !

    Shall we meet in Switzerland, neutral ground, where everyone is neutral, for a cup of coffee?

    Oh come on, women, education, what are you talking about? My mother, class 1947 has a PhD in Economy and Trade taken at the university of Catania in the 70s. She wasn’t secluded or fed only with bread and water or anything of the sort. My own sisters have doctorates in Law and Architecture. They weren’t publicly executed either! A million women I know are simply astonishingly intelligent (not only for a Sicilian) and have at least one degree!

    I believe that you make mention of the happenings maybe of a small village in the area of Palermo. Sicily has an area of 25,000 square kilometres and a population of 5,000,000, so please, go have a look at Taormina, Catania, Siracusa, and other areas before writing such belittling generalizations.

    And the incestuous marriages, are you talking about your village right? Do you know that Malta, the ‘multicultural’ island just south of Sicily, has a much higher percentage of the same phenomenon? Besides, I am sure that in many villages of Spain, France, Pakistan, Jamaica, or China, there is the same problem. What are you talking about?

    You feel like an outsider in Sicily? Have you ever thought of moving outside of Sicily?

    Sorry if I sound a bit too direct but what you write non c’avi ne testa e manku pedi, I’m sure you understand Sicilian by now! I could go on forever with how beautiful Sicily is and good the food is etc, however I don’t want to respond to a cliché with another. Sicily and Sicilians are much, much more than what comes across from your description. As a Sicilian, I feel offended and called upon, and so I am simply replying. No offense intended. Thanks for your input anyway.

  2. Oh by the way, I forgot to mention something. I forgot to thank you. Thank you for having gone against the main stream movement northward, and having chose to go southward and live Sicily, something I am not doing myself, although I put Sicily under each step I take abroad, trying to convey the good values of Sicilians and Sicily to the people I meet through they way I interact with them in everyday situations. You must really love your husband (of course, he is Sicilian!) having left London for Sicily . Thank you for sharing your thoughts and for bringing up a Sicilian piece of life to a wider audience by means of the English language. All I am saying is that yours is a PIECE of reality, and that generalising is misleading. That is not the reality of Sicily, that is your reality. It could have happened anywhere in the world, I guess. Well, thanks again, and all the best. Salutamu!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: